Court rejects Competition Bureau’s appeal to block Rogers’ takeover of Shaw

Court rejects Competition Bureau’s appeal to block Rogers’ takeover of Shaw

news image

Business·Breaking

Canada’s Federal Court of Appeal has rejected the Competition Bureau’s request to block the takeover of Shaw by Rogers, a decision that removes one of the final hurdles standing in the way of the $20-billion merger from going ahead.

Only thing standing in way of deal now is ministerial approval

Pete Evans · CBC News

·

Rogers first proposed to take over telecom rival Shaw in 2021, and the deal has faced and overcome numerous regulatory hurdles but still isn’t finalized. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Canada’s Federal Court of Appeal has rejected the Competition Bureau’s request to block the takeover of Shaw by Rogers, a decision that removes one of the final hurdles standing in the way of the $20-billion merger from going ahead.

The merger, first proposed in 2021, would see Toronto-based Rogers Communications Inc. take over Calgary-based rival Shaw Communications Inc. in a move that would further consolidate Canada’s top-heavy telecommunications sector.

The deal has faced numerous regulatory hurdles since being proposed, but in a lengthy review process the companies have secured most of the approvals they require to consummate the deal. As part of that process, Rogers has agreed to sell Shaw’s wireless business, Freedom Mobile, to Quebec-based Videotron.

The Competition Bureau was a major sticking point and sought to block the merger on the grounds that it would be bad for consumers, but a tribunal rejected that argument last month.

The bureau appealed to a higher court to reconsider, and Tuesday’s hearing brought an end to that dispute, in the companies’ favour.

“According to the tribunal, this was not a particularly close case,” the judge said. “It found, I would say, on the evidence rather decisively that there was no substantial lessening of competition.”

WATCH | How do Canadian telecom bills compare to the rest of the world? 

How do Canada’s data prices compare to the rest of the world?

CBC Marketplace put Canada’s phone data prices to the test, asking phone users in other countries to do everyday activities that many Canadians wouldn’t dream of without a wifi connection.

Now that the Competition Bureau has been unsuccessful, the final hurdle standing in the way of the deal being consummated is the approval of federal Innovation Minister François-Philippe Champagne.

Champagne has previously said he would not allow the deal to go through as originally structured, and even with the divestment of Freedom Mobile, he has laid out a checklist of what would be needed to get his approval.

The minister has said he would rule on the merger only once there is “clarity on the ongoing legal process.”

In a tweet on Tuesday, Champagne said he “will be reviewing” the court’s ruling “closely” and added that he will “render  a decision in due course.”

Rogers, Shaw and Videotron have a self-imposed deadline of Jan. 31 to finalize the deal, but many such deadlines have come and gone in this lengthy process.

Officials from Rogers, Shaw and other stakeholders will be in Ottawa on Wednesday to testify in front of the House of Commons standing committee on industry and technology. While the hearing is likely to result in probing and intense questioning, the committee itself lacks the power to actually block the deal.

Consumer watchdog group the Public Interest Advocacy Centre says the court made a huge mistake in rejecting the Competition Bureau’s arguments.

“The public can only be suspicious that the powers that be want this deal to close — even if it means a decade of high wireless and internet prices for Canadians,” executive director and general counsel John Lawford said after the verdict.

“The court’s ruling means the Canadian Competition Act is utterly broken and needs to be radically rewritten to actually provide tools to block anti-competitive mergers.”

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Pete Evans is the senior business writer for CBCNews.ca. Prior to coming to the CBC, his work has appeared in the Globe & Mail, the Financial Post, the Toronto Star, and Canadian Business Magazine. Twitter: @p_evans Email: pete.evans@cbc.ca

    Business·BreakingCanada’s Federal Court of Appeal has rejected the Competition Bureau’s request to block the takeover of Shaw by Rogers, a decision that removes one of the final hurdles standing in the way of the $20-billion merger from going ahead.Only thing standing in way of deal now is ministerial approvalPete Evans · CBC News · Posted: Jan 24, 2023 10:37 AM EST | Last Updated: 15 minutes agoRogers first proposed to take over telecom rival Shaw in 2021, and the deal has faced and overcome numerous regulatory hurdles but still isn’t finalized. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)Canada’s Federal Court of Appeal has rejected the Competition Bureau’s request to block the takeover of Shaw by Rogers, a decision that removes one of the final hurdles standing in the way of the $20-billion merger from going ahead.The merger, first proposed in 2021, would see Toronto-based Rogers Communications Inc. take over Calgary-based rival Shaw Communications Inc. in a move that would further consolidate Canada’s top-heavy telecommunications sector.The deal has faced numerous regulatory hurdles since being proposed, but in a lengthy review process the companies have secured most of the approvals they require to consummate the deal. As part of that process, Rogers has agreed to sell Shaw’s wireless business, Freedom Mobile, to Quebec-based Videotron.The Competition Bureau was a major sticking point and sought to block the merger on the grounds that it would be bad for consumers, but a tribunal rejected that argument last month.The bureau appealed to a higher court to reconsider, and Tuesday’s hearing brought an end to that dispute, in the companies’ favour.”According to the tribunal, this was not a particularly close case,” the judge said. “It found, I would say, on the evidence rather decisively that there was no substantial lessening of competition.”WATCH | How do Canadian telecom bills compare to the rest of the world? How do Canada’s data prices compare to the rest of the world?CBC Marketplace put Canada’s phone data prices to the test, asking phone users in other countries to do everyday activities that many Canadians wouldn’t dream of without a wifi connection.Now that the Competition Bureau has been unsuccessful, the final hurdle standing in the way of the deal being consummated is the approval of federal Innovation Minister François-Philippe Champagne.Champagne has previously said he would not allow the deal to go through as originally structured, and even with the divestment of Freedom Mobile, he has laid out a checklist of what would be needed to get his approval.The minister has said he would rule on the merger only once there is “clarity on the ongoing legal process.”In a tweet on Tuesday, Champagne said he “will be reviewing” the court’s ruling “closely” and added that he will “render  a decision in due course.”Rogers, Shaw and Videotron have a self-imposed deadline of Jan. 31 to finalize the deal, but many such deadlines have come and gone in this lengthy process.Officials from Rogers, Shaw and other stakeholders will be in Ottawa on Wednesday to testify in front of the House of Commons standing committee on industry and technology. While the hearing is likely to result in probing and intense questioning, the committee itself lacks the power to actually block the deal.Consumer watchdog group the Public Interest Advocacy Centre says the court made a huge mistake in rejecting the Competition Bureau’s arguments.”The public can only be suspicious that the powers that be want this deal to close — even if it means a decade of high wireless and internet prices for Canadians,” executive director and general counsel John Lawford said after the verdict.”The court’s ruling means the Canadian Competition Act is utterly broken and needs to be radically rewritten to actually provide tools to block anti-competitive mergers.”ABOUT THE AUTHORPete Evans is the senior business writer for CBCNews.ca. Prior to coming to the CBC, his work has appeared in the Globe & Mail, the Financial Post, the Toronto Star, and Canadian Business Magazine. Twitter: @p_evans Email: pete.evans@cbc.ca

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *